NewsCourt of Appeal reaffirms, returns Kashamu as Senator ...

Court of Appeal reaffirms, returns Kashamu as Senator By; Bayo Akamo, Ibadan.


Court of Appeal reaffirms, returns Kashamu as Senator
By; Bayo Akamo, Ibadan.
The Court of Appeal sitting in Ibadan has reaffirmed and returned the Senator representing Ogun East in the National Assembly, Senator Buruji Kashamu.
The court in itss judgment upturned the October 9, 2015 judgment of the National and State Assembly Elections Petition Tribunal sitting in Abeokuta.
In the unanimous judgment, the Appeal Court held that Senator Kashamu’s appeal is meritorious and therefore succeeds, thereby setting aside the ruling of the elections tribunal and  returned Senator Kashamu as the winner of the march 28, 2015 senatorial election in Ogun East Senatorial district
Justice M.L Shuaib while reading the lead judgment, said the tribunal erred and was partisan by descending into the arena and scouted for evidence to nullify Kashamu’s election and truncate his victory and that it was curious, illogical and perverse of the tribunal to place so much reliance on the evidence of a prosecution witness labeled as PW 44 and further admit as evidence documents that were clearly inadmissible under the law and also act on such evidence to truncate Kashamu’s victory.
According to the Appeal panel comprising of Justices A.G Msheila, M.L Shuaib and Ignatius Agube , PW 44 who posed as a forensic expert had discredited himself during cross examination when he stated that anyone with prerequisite knowledge could do what he did and added that he had no degree in statistics, saying, “PW 44 sold himself out and the tribunal should not have held that he was an expert when he himself had agreed anyone could do what he did.
“No expert opinion is needed in this case since PW44 stated that anyone, even a layman could do what he did and he has no degree in statistics.
“There is no certification of the admitted print out by the said forensic expert so it is not an exhibit and he also sold himself out when he stated that the Appendix A, B and C which was his report was printed from a computer but the tribunal held that it was PW44’s statement on oath and not a print out,” the court said.
Also, the three man Appeal panel held that the case of Prince Dapo Abiodun and the All Progressive Congress (APC) is a non issue as the material used to nullify the results of elections in some polling units and order re-election is inadmissible in law, adding that, “the case of the first and second respondents (Abiodun and APC) in this appeal collapses like a pack of cards as the respondents fail to lay necessary foundation for the admissibility of the annexes. Exhibits A, B and C are expunged as inadmissible
“PW44 was a hatchet man brought to truncate the appellant’s victory and since his testimony is that he thoroughly analyzed some documents from INEC’s register and used a computer to draw a table and print it out, the annexes are indeed a printout. It is wrong of the tribunal to place so much reliance on the evidence of a discredited witness and use an inadmissible document to arrive at its judgment”
The Appeal  panel  adopted the same judgment for the cross petition filed by Prince Adedapo Abiodun.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Senator Ita Enang Describes NIgeria’s Lawmakers As Stooges

By; PATRICK TITUS, Uyo  The Senior Special Assistant to President Mohammedu Buhari on Niger Delta Affairs, Senator Ita Enang has...

MITOSATH Chief Scores Lagos Govt 1st To Implement Mass Administration Of Medicine Against Schistosomiasis Using Ward Level Strategy

By; MATTHEW UKACHUNWA, Lagos Lagos State is the first State in Nigeria to implement Mass Administration of Medicines against...

Aisha Buhari Cup: Morocco Stun Cameroon

By; AYO OJEDOKUN Lagos A brilliant goal by Fatima Tagnaout 13 minutes from time separated Cameroon and Morocco in the...

COVID-19: Our Isolation Centres Not Hit By Paucity Of Funds – Oyo Govt

*insists its providing needed funds for centres, personnel cost By; BAYO AKAMO, Ibadan  The Oyo State Ministry of Health, on Thursday  declared...
- Advertisement -spot_imgspot_img

2023: Engage In Aggressive Advocacy On Women Involvement In Governance In Nigeria, Minister Tasks Stakeholders

By; BAYO AKAMO, Ibadan Minister of Women Affairs, Dame Pauline Tallen on Thursday tasked stakeholders to engage in aggressive advocacy...

Nasarawa Varsity VC Commends NDLEA On Drug Fight As Agency Takes Drug War To Universities

By; SAMSON YAKI, Lafia The Vice Chancellor of Nasarawa State University Keffi, Professor Suleiman Mohammed has commended the effort of...

Must read

Nigeria cracked polio. So why does it have 3.5 million unvaccinated babies?

 By; Utibe Effiong Over 20 million children across the globe have...

AFCON: ‘Kaduna Fans scare me, remain best ever’ – Pinick

By; Abdull-Azeez Ahmed Kadir, Kaduna. No where in Nigeria has...

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you